jonboyd.org nothing hash
nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing ribbon

Search JonBoyd.org:

nothing
 

 

jonboyd.org

  Books
Portuguese Irregular Verbs by Alexander McCall Smith
   
   

No, this is not a how-to book to help you get ready for your vacation in Lisbon or Brazil. Now that you mention it, though: what kind of book is this?

Smith, Portuguese Irregular Verbs
source: Amazon
The two words that come to mind when I reflect on this slim book of fiction are "whimsical" and "melancholy." Alexander McCall Smith is perhaps best known as the author of the "Mma Ramotswe" mysteries, starting with The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency. But Smith's day job is as professor of Medical Law at the University of Edinburgh, and for Portuguese Irregular Verbs he has dipped into the twisted subculture of the academy to create one of the strangest fictional characters I've ever encountered: Professor Dr Moritz-Maria von Igelfeld.

This first book in a series that now runs to three volumes follows von Igelfeld (German for "hedgehog") from his grad school days through the events of his early career as an emerging scholar who becomes famous for his masterpiece, Portuguese Irregular Verbs.

The jacket blurb describes von Igelfeld as "a blend of the cultivated pomposity of Frasier Crane and of Inspecteur Clouseau." Good comparisons — and another I'd bring in would be the series of films running from Waiting for Guffman through Best in Show and A Mighty Wind. In those movies, as here, the subject is a strange subculture with devotées who are no less comical for how serious they are. And like those films, Smith's "tall novel" of life in the academy may simultaneously charm and cut a bit too close for comfort.

The best chapter is "Italian Matters," which takes von Igelfeld on a sojourn to a small village near Siena. Here Smith is at his best, combining glowing descriptions of the countryside with the central tragi-comic account of his protagonist's encounter with xenophobia. I was moved by Smith's deft hand in sketching von Igelfeld's deep conditioning to miss the sublime and dwell on the small social slights of an academic's life.

In short, my guess is that non-academics will find this book so quirky that they either laugh loud and long or think it's just weird. But academics may find plenty to mull over in Smith's small sketches of one pathetic academic's bumblings through life.

   
   

first published May 5, 2004

« previous   {in the Reviews Department}  next »

Departments:  Ministry  ·  News  ·  Reviews  ·  Words

   
  about   contact   JonBoyd.org is produced by the Octothorp Press, Chicago
© 2003-2007 by Jonathan Boyd
rev. 2004.09.11
 
nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing